Saturday, 7 January 2012

Weekly Round-up w/e 8/01/2012


Welcome to the latest round-up. Let's have a look what the first full week of 2012 has for us. Hmm.

A quick reminder first that Andy McIntosh will be joining us at the Vic for our
first talk of 2012. He's a Professor of Thermodynamics but also a devout Christian and Young Earth Creationist, so expect the night to be lively. Also later in the month we have our first Social of the year on Tuesday 24th at the Square Peg in Corporation Street, and make a note of future dates as we have Alice Sheppard (@penguingalaxy) in February and Deborah Hyde (@jourdemayne) in March.

In local news  a new group called
Birmingham Girl Geeks launches on Saturday 21st January at the Urban Coffee Company in Church Street with guest speaker Denise Jacobs and Birmingham now has a MathsJam which meets on the last Tuesday of the month at the Tap and Spile in Gas Street. It clashes with our Social this month but you can go next month can't you?

Slightly further afield, the speakers at
Thinkcon on 17th March in Cambridge have been announced with an impressive line-up (FB & Twitter). It's a week after QEDcon in Manchester, so for those who wanted another QED the weekend after last year's, here's your chance.

Skeptic news on the net includes the launch of a monthly page of actions to familiarise yourselves and others of psychic's tricks and scams. This month is on
newspaper astrology & Barnum statements.

Also just released are
Professor Bruce Hood's Royal Institution Christmas Lectures. All of them appear to be up and here's the first.

One of the big stories of the week is the instigation of legal proceedings by the disgraced ex-doctor Andrew Wakefield who claimed a connection between the MMR vaccine and autism and was struck off for unethical procedures carried out on children from which they gained no benefit. He claims his reputation has been, err,
damaged by an article published a year ago. A running round-up of articles is being collated by @lizditz here and for those of a legal bent I'd recommend the thoughts of the Skeptical Lawyer and of Ken at Popehat highlighting Texas's new anti-SLAPP statute designed to stop actions like this. There are some interesting theories on why Wakefield might be taking this action using a non-specialist lawyer despite his small chance of success. As Orac says, the plot thickens.

This case may seem far removed from us, however libel threats and actions continue to surface on a weekly basis. Vaughan Jones from Nuneaton has a case going through the High Court as I type. There's more on the case here, but as the review and articles in question have been removed from public view we'll have to wait until matters conclude to see what all the fuss was about. We wish him well. Here's his take on the state of our current libel laws and why it should matter.

Also this week, news has reached us of William Foxton who has lost his job at Chamber Report, a magazine highlighting the great and the good (and the bad) in the legal profession, for green-lighting a story in which the facts do not seem to be in question. The story involves an individual who, despite having been hung out to dry by his own legal firm in Dubai, has an awful lot of money.
It's a desperately sad indictment of how our libel laws currently work. After reading that I'll just leave this here. It's the homepage of the Libel Reform Campaign. They have a donations page. Just saying.

There is also disquiet in the psychiatric profession as preparation of DSM5, the latest Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders referred to by Jon Ronson when he visited us in July,
seems to be being hindered by the legal insistence of confidentiality clauses and commercialism.

Right, let's point and laugh at things religious for a bit. Always fun, but the first are not aimed at the believer but at the atheist or skeptic. Many will have heard of the fact that radical islamic extremists who blow themselves and others to pieces in the name of their deity ascend to paradise to be greeted by 72 virgins. Well, I say “fact”. If I were you I'd take a look at
this from skepchicks. Maybe those who recently explained to someone how Christmas was stolen from the story of Mithras or Dionysus or Horus should have a wee look here and here too.

The Telegraph reported this week that
Scientology “is becoming a hollow moneymaking machine run by an autocratic ruler” as yet another senior devotee takes a pop at the top dog claiming that the cult longer adheres to the “teachings” of L Ron Hubbard. Here's hoping they implode.

Some outright idiocy now as someone muses as to what
would have happened had Jesus not existed. It reads like it should be a Poe, but I suspect not.

Lastly, as we're talking religion, there's obviously some nastiness as highlighted in this piece on the practise of
muddying the waters between science and religion to indoctrinate children.

A wonderful blog now, from Richard Wilson (@dontgetfooled) on the problems of “policy-based evidence-making”, how those in public life cherry-pick evidence with no qualms and what is being done about it.

A question sometimes raised at Skeptics in the Pub meetings to speakers who are active in the realms of alternative medicines is why skeptics seem to gravitate towards alt med and not take on broader spheres such as politics, The reasons why the latter are difficult is discussed in the above blog however, specifically, people blog about CAM because the mainstream media in this country predominantly give it a free ride as shown here by @jdc325

I suppose that now gives me licence to point out that taking Vitamin D will not help people avoid heart attacks or cancer and the horrendous unpleasantness of publishing a book aimed at “4-10 year olds on... ...the ineffectiveness of vaccines” (sic).

On a slightly related note, this is one reason why
you shouldn't have certain New Year's Resolutions.

As for the mainstream and printed media you could learn from the Telegraph (again) that there are no longer any homeopathy degree courses in Britain and that other CAM courses are in steep decline however it is bewildering to see that Nature seem to have allowed inclusion of a supplement in their magazine on Traditional Asian Medicine (sic) and seem happy to state that they carry “sole responsibility for all editorial content”. I wonder if the cash was worth it.

Following on from Sense about Science's
Celebrities and Science pdf as mentioned last time (worth a look if you missed it) we can now bring you the Climate Crock BS of the Year Awards. There are some fun (and occasionally funny videos)  and the usual suspects are there although there is a slant towards Americans. And Republicans. And Christians. And people with lots of money and oil companies. Prepare to facepalm or headdeak (your choice).

This last blog blows a hole in the “more expensive is better” meme that seems to permeate society but this time in music. Do you think you could tell the difference between a Stradivarius violin and a new one? Ed Yong shows that you can't,
and neither can the experts. That said, to some people especially Paypal, value matters.

As I mentioned virgins above, I thought I'd leave you with a video of a virgin birth in fact the fourth virgin birth in four years. There's the minimum of pain and gloop though, very little intervention during the birth and it is unlikely to give anyone nightmares.

Unless you're a shark.

This week's round-up was written by Chris Richardson (
@christheneck) with additional links provided by Roy Beddowes.

Monday, 2 January 2012

Round-Up W/e 1/1/12

Hello and welcome to the first round-up of the year.  We're looking forward to 2012 as we have a host of interesting speakers lined up as well as some very special guests that we've not managed to pin down to an exact date yet.  Happy New Year to you all, here's the round-up.


Here’s Richard Dawkins talking about our next speaker, Professor Andy McIntosh of Leeds University.  Andy will be with us on Wednesday 11th January at The Vic as always.  The talk is entitled ‘A Sceptical View of Atheism’ and we’re looking forward to some lively debate.  Details of the talk are here.

Hertfordshire Police have begun to use polygraphs to detect lies told by sex offenders.  Bruce Burgess, a former chairman of the British Polygraph Association (BPA) is in favour of this you’ll be surprised to learn.  Independent tests have found it to be little better than chance.  For those that require a little more evidence than the word of those with interests, then here’s a review of the current scientific status by the British Psychological Society.

Lie detection has never fared well when subjected to scientific rigour, the Department of Work and Pensions trialled Voice Risk Analysis (VRA) software in 2008 to detect benefit cheats.  They found it to be not sufficiently reliable and therefore decided not to introduce it.  The company that supplied the VRA software got upset and sent the lawyers in, another example of libel threatening science in the UK.

Cee-Lo green has spoketh, all ye atheists repent.  According to that bloke that sang that song last year, you know the one that had swearing in it sometimes, all religion is true.  He decided to cover John Lennon’s Imagine and change the bit that goes “and all religions too” to “and all religion is true” the prat.  FU Cee-Lo (DYSWIDT?)

JOB SECTION: Famous physicist requires computer genius to maintain wheelchair with integrated custom-built computer-controlled voice synthesiser.

PAREIDOLIA CORNER: Another Jesus one (Isn’t it always?), this time in the Telegraph, perhaps they’d run out of pictures of pretty young women or bashed the BBC all they could this week.  So, Jesus has appeared in the crumple of a sock, thanks for that The Telegraph.

It’s the Sense about Science (SAS) annual review, always good for a laugh and a cry.  SAS correct some of the bullshit spouted by celebrities throughout the preceding year.  According to one ‘famous’ person, the sea is salty due to whale sperm.  Another regurgitates the old detox stuff and, more dangerously, the anti-vax myths are squirted into our ears.  Tracey Brown talks about the review here.

Nice to see the BBC prominently reporting the detox is claptrap story.  My Facebook feed is always full of discussion of detox products at this time of the year, sadly not concerning the evidence base.

Police time is wasted by people requesting information of reports into zombies, UFOs, werewolves etc.  That is according to Chief Constable Ian Arundale of Dyfed Powys Police of course, maybe he’s just saying that because he’s scared that people are cottoning onto the truth that these things are among us.  “There’s no evidence for it, but it is scientific fact” Dr ‘Neil’ Fox.

Suzanne Somers is famous in America and she survived breast cancer.  She underwent a lumpectomy and radiation treatment. Oh, and she also had injections of mistletoe extract.  In her opinion, it wasn’t the evidence-based treatment she received that helped her survive, it was the mistletoe.  Now she has become a scientific guru touring the talk show circuit and selling her book.  Joe Schwarcz writes about Pseudo-scientific blather and star power, a crazy mix.

Fresh from taking on ‘mongs’ and ‘the PC brigade’, Ricky Gervais has turned his attention to more worthy targets, fundamentalist Christians.  This is not in anyway a PR move after his recent bad press.

Rebecca Watson calls out inappropriate behaviour in atheist reddit groups.

Cracked ran a list recently of 4 things both atheists and believers need to stop saying.  Kazim responds to this.

It seems that the Righteous Indignation podcast has come to an end, at least for the moment.  Hayley Stevens talks here about ‘Talk about Strange’, her new podcast which is a relaunch of the Ghost Field Guide.

The Telegraph is not looking good in this week’s round-up, now we have someone who believes the war on Christmas is real, and on top of that, the atheist barbarians are winning.

God has announced crab 2.0, now with forward motion.



Sadly, Tim Minchin's excellent Woody Allen Jesus song got cut from the transmission of Jonathan Ross' ITV show. Here it is:





This week's Round-Up was patched together by Birmingham Skeptics co-organiser Paul Bryant (@thebigyeti)

Monday, 19 December 2011

Weekly Round Up w/e 18/12/2011


T'was the week before Christmas and all through the… no wait, that's probably the wrong audience.  Welcome to the weekly round up of skeptical goodness - plenty of stuff to fill your stockings and keep you busy right up until Christmas!

Far from being humbugs, every good Skeptic enjoys a bit of festive joy this time of year.  Coventry Skeptics are meeting on Wednesday (21st Dec) to hear about a Skeptic's Guide to Christmas and despite what ol' Dave says, there's a place for godlessness at Christmas as New Humanist launches the Nine Days of Godless Christmas Podcasts and Lauren at Friendly Atheist describes how to decorate your tree atheist style.  Plus The Royal Institution's Christmas Lectures this year return with experimental psychologist Prof Bruce Hood who is delivering a three part series called Meet Your Brain.  Personally I'm hoping for at least one mention of zombies…

Oh and if you're still looking for Christmas presents, shame on you.  But the Brain Pickings 11 Best Science books might be a good pick, alternatively a DVD box-set of TV series The Big Bang Theory if you want to get youngsters into physics, according to this article in the Observer.  But you might want to stay away from candles (burning ones might cause cancer) or crying baby ringtones which have been claimed boost breast size.

Enough about Christmas though.  Apparently the Large Hadron Collider has finally proven useful by finding Brian Cox's car keys.  And if you don't know what the LHC and its efforts to find the Higgs boson are about, then this article in New Scientist might be of some interest.  It's, like, something to do with physics and our existence or summat.  But even if the Higgs Boson isn't found that's a-okay according to Jon Butterworth at the Guardian.

You can't help but have heard about the whole #Burzynski and his antieoplastins as a "cancer cure".  British media, including the BBC, the Observer and most latest the London Evening Standard (who at least have a sentence alluding to criticism about the clinic), have been promoting fundraising efforts by British patients to get to the clinic in the US, despite wide-spread criticism from skeptics, scientists and Cancer Research.  In fact there's a whole heap of skeptical blogposts on the Burzynski Clinic and its favourable media coverage from QuackometerTwentyFirstFloorMinistry of Truth and the Science-Based medicine blog and are knocking about and worth a read. The Nature has also covered how the press might be under pressure in regards to scientific ignorance in British press too.

Speaking of alternative and complementary medicines (CAM for short), the British Acupuncture Council have provided an info pack on how they might be able to set up NHS acupuncture services.  Quite why you'd lay out your arguments for the opposing side to rip to pieces is beyond me, but its worth a look.  There's a fairly interesting Freedom of Information request about current use of acupuncture in the NHS in there.  Seems the local PCTs (B'ham East and North, Heart of Birmingham, but not South Birmingham) use acupuncture, but most interesting are the barriers to use with evidence being cited quite a lot.  Although Quackometer did blog to warn about this as a possibility back in 2010.

UK Skeptics have also stumbled across the Spirit Release Foundation who talk about spirit attachment (although really it's just their guidance that the website is best viewed in MS Explorer 5 or better that pains me).  And over in the US the Chicago Tribune reports on the troubled study at heart of therapy debate.

And whilst most of the skeptical community would like to see stronger regulation of CAM, a recent beheading of a women in Saudi Arabia for 'sorcery' as religious police said she tricked people into claiming she could treat illnesses is really not the way to go.

It can't have escaped your notice that it's nearly the end of the year, which of course means it's time to get voting for The Skeptic Magazine's Skeptic Awards 2011.  There are five categories this year including best podcast and blog, with the awards ceremony being held at QED in March.  There doesn't seem to be a closing date on the website for nominations, but better get voting sooner rather than later.  If you're stuck for a podcast, might we remind you to glance right at that box a few inches down…

And to round off a humorous and definitely not safe-for-work video from ZOMGGitsCriss on why she is not agnostic-athiest and why atheism and agnosticism aren't the same thing.


Here at Brum Skeptics we like any excuse for a knees up, so godless or not we'd like to wish you happy holidays and see you all next year for "A Sceptical View of Atheism."

This week's round up was compiled by Birmingham Skeptics in the Pub organiser Laura Creavan


Sunday, 11 December 2011

Weekly Roundup week ending 11/12/2011


Hello and welcome to the Birmingham Skeptics weekly roundup of the good, the bad and the sometimes ridiculous from the world of science and skepticism. We had our last meet of the year this week with David Allen Green and it was great to get chance to chat to people at the end. Make sure you check our website and join the Facebook group to keep up with all upcoming events and socials.

Time for business, we’ll kick off with an excellent bit of paradolia as the Mail brings us this wonderfully creepy image from beneath the ground. Sticking with fantastic images over at the Friendly Atheist we have some controversy as the combination of the Bible, Lego and explicit sex scenes (albeit with no genitals) proves too much for some retailers.

A nice post here looking at the correlation between religiosity and the declineof science literacy in the States. In a similar vein the Turkish government feel that the young need protecting from Darwin and evolution.



I’ll insert a quick and shameless plug for our latest podcast here. This one has a bit of swearing in it but it’s a good one. You can stream it here or find the iTunes details here. It’s me interviewing a couple of skeptical podcasters from America and it’s lively and funny. Look out for upcoming podcasts, the next one will have Becs O’Neill the Skeprechaun.
A serious and sad article from the Observer next, although it’s a story and theme long covered by Private Eye, so let’s tip a hat to them. It’s the case of Carole Myers who died amidst claims that she had suffered satanic abuse at the hands of her parents. Chris French features in here and anyone who saw him at the talk he gave at the Brum Skeptics will know his interest and scepticism about recovered memories.

We’ve just passed the anniversary of the death of John Lennon. I can’t believe it was 31 years ago! This blog marks that sad event but finishes on an upbeat note that’s worth a read by those involved in skepticism.

Another well known speaker on the skeptics circuit had an article out this week. Nick Pope writes about unexplained structures, aliens and conspiracies with some great photos.

If you weren’t already excited enough about the upcoming QED conference in March, they’ve just announced that there will be a skeptical award ceremony there. Even if you can’t make it to the event you can still try to ensure that your favourite skeptical endeavours receive the reward and recognition that they deserve.

And finally a video. It’s not particularly skeptical but I love octopuses and I’ve put this together so you’re going to have to put up with it. Besides, it is very very cool. Give them a few million more years of evolution and they might be moving into a neighbourhood near you. That is how it works right? Just enjoy the video and don't worry whether it's octopuses, octopi or octopodes, it's an eight legged wonder!


This week's roundup was put together by Patrick Redmond (@paddyrex)

Sunday, 4 December 2011

Birmingham Skeptics Weekly Round-up: w/e 04.12.11

We’ve rounded up a big round thing again this week for you nice people at Birmingham Skeptics; and with a surplus of great links stewing in the skeptic pot from November’s cultic milieu we’ve decided to roll them all up into nice little bite-size chunks for your digestion.

There’s a lot to get through, here’s the first of our offerings..

Tuesday, 29 November 2011

Would you kick a dying man?

The skeptical community is buzzing with news and views on the Burzynski Clinic with many well known bloggers rightfully lining up to deplore their bullying tactics and lack of evidence. It's a scientific battle though in which most of us are not always directly touched but there are those that are. Those claiming to heal cancer will happily parade hopeful people willing to give testimony on their behalf so it's worth stopping to listen to the other side. Below is an introduction by one of Birmingham Skeptics in the Pub's regular attendees with a link to her blog about  her family's experience. Please take the time to look through it.




"When sceptics challenge cancer quackery they are often accused of robbing people of their hope. Sceptics are made to feel mean for taking away the ‘last chance’ of a dying person, as if they don’t want to see the dying person recover. This is my blog where I talk about my dad who is dying of cancer and the harm that is being done to him and my family by this cancer quackery. Much of the cancer quackery he has encountered is from individuals who are using their status as doctors or nurses to advertise their businesses yet they are selling treatments that are outside of the medical establishment. I find it upsetting that my mum will say ‘well she is a nurse so it’s not quackery’ when describing the herbal supplements and remedies she is getting for my dad, if these people feel so strongly that the ‘establishment’ is wrong they should not use it to add legitimacy to what they do."


Sunday, 27 November 2011

Weekly round-up w/e 27/11/11


Welcome to this week's round-up. First up, we are looking forward to hosting, David Allen Green, Lawyer, Blogger as Jack of Kent, Legal correspondent of New Statesman, media correspondent of The Lawyer, convenor of Westminster Skeptics, Brummie and Villa fan on Thursday 8th December (yes Thursday) who will be taking time out from his obviously empty schedule to talk on Birmingham and free thought - from Joseph Priestley onwards. Things kick off at 7.30pm at The Vic with drinkies and chat before, during and after so get yourself along. This is our last meet until the New Year when we will return to Wednesdays (and not Thursdays).

A lot has come up this week, some silly, some foolish and some plain vile but as always there's fun to be had along the way.

First up,