Monday, 18 July 2011

South Korea's Medical Professionals Crack Down on Chiropractors


A blog post by Bayani Mills (@bayanimills)

Members of the Korean Chiropractic Association in South Korea are in uproar at the scrutiny of their profession, after an investigation of formal Chiropractic clinics by local health authorities has led to more legal proceedings. Taeg Su Choi, KCA president since 2003, who has faced five prosecutions himself since that time, claims the proceedings are a result of complaints from two of South Korea's professional medical associations, the Korean Medical Association and the Oriental Medical Doctors' Association.

Disputes about the Chiropractors have been ongoing since its introduction in the 1990's when South Korea's first Chiropractor, Yong Serb, returned after attending the Palmer College of Chiropractic in the USA. Serb, the founder and first president of the Korean Chiropractic Association has been convicted three times for breaking South Korean laws.

Under the law, It is illegal for independent Chiropractors to practise. If you were a Medical Doctor who took some seminar classes in Chiropractic or similar manipulative therapies, you could legally practice those techniques, however, someone who just went to a Chiropractic college in America, the UK, or Australia could not legally practice in Korea.

According to the World Federation of Chiropractic, the Korean Chiropractic Association once had over 60 members, which has since fallen to 17 as a result of the convictions of so many of its members. On 30th June 2011 a World Federation of Chiropractic media release explained the argument used in defence of their practice at appeals at the Constitutional Court: "Their argument has been that Koreans have a constitutional right to choose and receive natural forms of health care that relieve pain and suffering, and that Chiropractors have a constitutional right to offer those services."

Appeals from the Members of the KCA claim that the law is unconstitutional, however, while this defence erroneously characterizes the law as being "anti-Chiropractic", South Korean law doesn't state that Chiropractic is illegal. Rather, the law states Chiropractors can't practice their techniques unless they're qualified Medical Doctors.

The issue of right to choice has been the crux of many appeals by "alternative" health advocates, and in South Korea Chiropractors are not alone, with Acupuncturists also feeling the sting dealt out by the courts for not practising within the law.

... apparently, robust evidence-based medical training is too much to ask in other parts of the world too.

Bayani Mills is an amateur skeptic with an interest in science and technology. More of his promotion of critical thinking and skeptical activism can be found at his website.

 

9 comments:

G WIlson said...

Chiropractic care has been seen as a skeptical cure of back and neck pain since it was first practiced in the 1960's.


chiropractor adelaide

Jerry Hochman said...

If you have never been helped by a chiropractor, there are only 2 possibilities:
1. You have never been to one, or
2. The one you went to was not a good one. Most are very good.

Dr. Jerry Hochman said...

Chiropractic was first practiced in 1895 in Davenport, Iowa by D.D. Palmer. Get your facts straight before showing ignorance.

Anonymous said...

First practiced in the 1960's???
Ha!! Chiropractic has been around for over 100 years

Moriene carl said...

At Perimeter Spine we take physical rehabilitation very seriously, in fact, we focus on being the best at it. From the evaluation to the diagnosis and down to all our physical medicine treatments, you can be certain that you will be getting only the best care every step of the way. perimeter spine and rehabilitation center

back pain treatment nj said...

I found your website the other day and after reading a handful of posts, thought I would say thank you for all the great content. Keep it coming! I will try to stop by here more often.

Victory Rehab said...

Interesting post. There are some benefits here, having only certified chiropractors is important to avoid the bad name some people try to give chiropractors.

drnunno said...

Medical doctors have been intimidated by chiropractors forever. Follow the money.

Get adjusted---get healthy!!

Rocks said...

Very nice and informative article. Read US open tennis champions